Civil and commercial mediation
Mediation for business, contract, property and money disputes: how a mediation day runs, why the courts now expect it, and how to choose a mediator.
Civil and commercial mediation covers disputes about money, contracts, property and business relationships. It is used by sole traders and multinationals alike, and increasingly the courts of England and Wales expect parties to have tried it before they litigate.
What it is used for
Almost any dispute that could end up in a civil court can be mediated. Common examples include:
- Contract disputes between businesses, or between a business and a customer
- Unpaid invoices and debt recovery
- Disputes between shareholders, directors or business partners
- Property and landlord and tenant disagreements, including boundaries, dilapidations and service charges
- Construction and building disputes
- Professional negligence claims
- Insurance claims
- Inheritance and probate disputes
- Intellectual property disputes
- Personal injury and clinical negligence claims
The common thread is that the parties want a resolution more than they want a judgment. Mediation lets them reach one on their own terms, usually in a day, and keep control of the cost.
How a commercial mediation runs
Civil and commercial mediation is usually a single day, though smaller disputes may take half a day and very large ones may take two.
Before the day. The parties agree on a mediator and sign a mediation agreement, which sets out confidentiality and fees. Each side sends the mediator a short position statement and the key documents. The mediator will often have a call with each side beforehand.
On the day. The mediator typically opens with a short joint session, then moves between the parties in separate rooms. These private sessions are the heart of the process. The mediator tests each side's assumptions, explores what is really driving the dispute, and carries offers between the rooms. Nothing said in a private session is passed on without permission.
The agreement. If a deal is reached, it is written up and signed on the day. In civil and commercial mediation a signed settlement agreement is a binding contract. If proceedings have already started, it is usually recorded in a consent order, often in the form known as a Tomlin order.
Lawyers usually attend commercial mediations with their clients. They are not required, and in smaller disputes people often represent themselves, but on larger matters it is normal to have advice in the room.
Why the courts care
The courts have moved steadily towards expecting mediation. Three developments matter most:
Costs. For many years a party who unreasonably refused to mediate has risked a costs penalty even if they won. That principle still stands.
Churchill v Merthyr Tydfil (2023). The Court of Appeal confirmed that courts can order parties to engage in mediation or another form of non-court dispute resolution, and can stay proceedings while they do, provided the order does not prevent access to a fair trial. The Civil Procedure Rules were amended in 2024 to reflect this.
Small claims. Since May 2024, most money claims under £10,000 on the small claims track are automatically referred to a free telephone mediation appointment run by HM Courts and Tribunals Service before the case can go to a hearing.
The practical effect is that mediation is now part of the normal path of a civil dispute, not an optional extra.
Mediation and without prejudice
Mediation discussions are confidential and "without prejudice", which means that what is said cannot normally be referred to in court if the mediation does not settle. This protection is what allows people to speak frankly about their position. The settlement agreement itself, once signed, is an ordinary contract and can be enforced like any other.
Choosing a civil or commercial mediator
The Civil Mediation Council maintains a register of mediators who have completed accredited training, carry professional indemnity insurance and keep up continuing professional development. Registered mediators are listed as Associate, Registered or Fellow depending on experience. Accreditation from a recognised training body such as CEDR, the Society of Mediators, the London School of Mediation or CIArb is the usual route onto the register.
Beyond accreditation, look for someone with experience in the kind of dispute you have, and with a style that suits the people involved. See how to choose a mediator for more.
For costs, see what does mediation cost.