Skip to main content

How to choose a mediator

Accreditation bodies, experience, style and practicalities, with the questions worth asking before you book.

The mediator you choose shapes how the process feels and how likely it is to succeed. There is no single right answer, but there are a few things that matter in almost every case.

Start with the type of dispute

Mediation is one profession with several distinct practice areas, and the training and regulation differ:

  • Family mediation is regulated by the Family Mediation Council. Only an FMC accredited mediator can sign a MIAM certificate for court or do legal aid work. See family mediation.
  • Civil and commercial mediation is overseen by the Civil Mediation Council, which registers mediators who have completed accredited training and maintain insurance and continuing development. See civil and commercial mediation.
  • Workplace mediation draws on both the civil framework and specialist HR and employment training. See workplace mediation.
  • Community mediation is mostly delivered by local services with their own trained volunteers. See community mediation.

A mediator who is excellent in one of these areas may have no experience in another. Match the mediator to the dispute first.

Check accreditation

Ask where the mediator trained and which body they are registered with. The main names you will see in the UK are:

  • Family Mediation Council (FMC), which publishes a register of accredited family mediators (FMCA)
  • Civil Mediation Council (CMC), which registers civil, commercial and workplace mediators at Associate, Registered and Fellow level
  • Training and accrediting bodies such as CEDR, the Society of Mediators, the London School of Mediation, the Chartered Institute of Arbitrators (CIArb) and the College of Mediators
  • Resolution, the family law organisation, many of whose members are also mediators

Accreditation tells you the mediator has met a recognised standard, carries professional indemnity insurance, follows a code of conduct and has a complaints procedure. It does not tell you they are the right person for your dispute.

Look at relevant experience

Ask how many mediations the mediator has done, and how many in disputes like yours. A mediator who has handled fifty landlord and tenant cases will understand the dynamics of your boundary dispute faster than a generalist. In commercial work, sector knowledge helps, but the ability to run a difficult day well matters more than subject expertise.

Many mediators publish case summaries or feedback on their websites. Some will put you in touch with a solicitor who has instructed them.

Consider style

Mediators differ in approach. Some are facilitative: they help the parties communicate and leave the content of any settlement entirely to them. Others are more evaluative: they will, if asked, give a view on the strengths and weaknesses of each side's position. Most sit somewhere in between and adjust to the case.

Think about which would help. In a dispute where the parties are far apart on the law, an evaluative mediator with legal experience can be useful. In a family or workplace dispute where the relationship is what matters, a facilitative approach is usually better.

Practicalities

Location and format. Most mediators now work online as well as in person. Online mediation suits many disputes and saves travel costs. In-person tends to be preferred for complex commercial matters and where body language matters.

Availability. Ask how soon the mediator can offer a date. Delay rarely helps a dispute.

Fees. Ask for a written quote that sets out what is included: preparation, the day itself, any overrun, and travel. See what does mediation cost.

Neutrality. The mediator should have no connection with either side. If the other party has proposed a mediator, you are entitled to check their background and to suggest alternatives.

Questions worth asking

1. Which body are you accredited by, and can I see your register entry? 2. How many mediations have you conducted in disputes like this one? 3. How do you usually structure the day, or the sessions? 4. Would you describe your style as facilitative, evaluative, or a mix? 5. What is your fee, and what does it include? 6. Do you have any connection with the other party or their advisers? 7. What happens if we do not reach agreement on the day?

A good mediator will answer these without hesitation. If you have to push for straight answers before the mediation, that tells you something about how the mediation will go.